Logo for Vitruvian Fitness of Wheat Ridge

Our Top 20 Supplement Recommendations - IF You Should Take Any At All

Tom Wigginton • April 12, 2025

Supplements can be useful. Sometimes they’re even necessary. But figuring out if, when, and why you should use them is a more complicated question than most headlines, influencers, or supplement companies want to admit. In a perfect world, we’d get all the micronutrients, minerals, and performance-optimizing compounds we need from real food, sunlight, sleep, and clean living. In the real world, though—where stress is high, schedules are full, and food quality varies—strategic supplementation can fill gaps, enhance recovery, improve long-term health, or support performance.


But here’s the problem: the supplement space is a minefield. Outdated “bro science,” influencer hype, fairy-tale claims, and straight-up lies have created a noisy mess that makes choosing the right supplement—if you even need one—much harder than it should be. And remember: no two bodies are exactly alike. Your age, gender, activity level, medical history, diet, goals, and lifestyle all influence what your body might be missing (or absorbing poorly). Supplementation isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution—it’s a strategy. That strategy should begin with lab work, conversations with qualified professionals, and clear priorities.


Disclaimer:
This guide is not medical advice or a prescription. It’s an information tool designed to help you better understand what supplements may—or may not—support your personal health, performance, or longevity goals. Before starting any new supplement, consult with a qualified healthcare or functional nutrition professional, especially if you have preexisting conditions, take medications, or are managing complex health goals.

Meal Planning with ChatGPT at Vitruvian Fitness

Top 20 Supplements Ranked for Longevity, Aging, Recovery, and Athletic Performance


Introduction


This ranked list attempts to prioritize supplements based on their value for longevity, healthy aging, recovery, and athletic performancein that order. If your priorities are different, the ranking of these supplements might change or look quite different.


Each supplement is evaluated using scientific literature (not market hype), considering:


🔹 Primary Use


✅ Pros & ⚠️ Cons

🧬 Best and 🚫 Worst users

♀/♂Gender-specific nuance, where relevant

⚔️ Conflicting evidence, if applicable


🔬Highly cited references


Supplements popular due to marketing or legacy use (like glucosamine or fat burners) were either demoted or excluded. This list is intended to educate consumers who want to age well, recover intelligently, and train sustainably.


Here's Our List of the Top 20


1. Vitamin D3 (Cholecalciferol)

🔹 Use: Bone health, immune regulation, mood, aging support
✅ Pros: Easy to supplement, addresses widespread deficiency, supports immunity and calcium absorption
⚠️ Cons: Requires blood testing; fat-soluble, so toxicity risk exists with long-term high doses
🧬 Best for: Indoor workers, older adults, darker-skinned individuals, northern climates
🚫 Worst for: Individuals already getting excess D3 from multiple sources without lab monitoring
♀/♂: Especially crucial for post-menopausal women (bone health)
🔬 Reference: Holick MF (2007).
NEJM. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMra070553

2. Omega-3s (EPA/DHA)

🔹 Use: Cardiovascular and brain health, inflammation reduction
✅ Pros: Supports cognitive aging, cardiovascular function, and joint recovery
⚠️ Cons: Quality varies; risk of oxidation; fishy burps for some
🧬 Best for: Anyone not eating fatty fish 2–3x/week, inflammatory issues
🚫 Worst for: People on anticoagulants or poor-quality supplement users
♀/♂: Women may convert ALA more efficiently but still benefit from direct EPA/DHA
🔬 Reference: Mozaffarian D, Wu JHY (2011).
J Am Coll Cardiol. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0735109711031317

3. Magnesium (Glycinate or Citrate)
🔹 Use: Sleep, muscle and nerve function, blood pressure, mood

✅ Pros: Involved in 300+ enzyme processes; helps sleep, stress, and metabolic health
⚠️ Cons: Citrate may cause loose stools; many forms are poorly absorbed
🧬 Best for: Stressed individuals, poor sleepers, older adults
🚫 Worst for: Over-supplementers or multivitamin users
♀/♂: Women benefit during menstruation and menopause-related insomnia
🔬 Reference: de Baaij JHF et al. (2015). Physiol Rev. https://doi.org/10.1152/physrev.00012.2014

4. Creatine Monohydrate

🔹 Use: Strength, cognition, lean mass preservation
✅ Pros: Neuroprotective, improves performance, supports muscle and possibly brain aging
⚠️ Cons: Water retention; occasional GI issues
🧬 Best for: Older adults, lifters, vegetarians
🚫 Worst for: Kidney disease (precautionary)
♀/♂: Especially helpful post-menopause for strength and cognitive support
🔬 Reference: Kreider et al. (2017). JISSN. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12970-017-0173-z

5. Protein Powder (Whey, Casein, or Plant-Based)
🔹 Use: Muscle maintenance, recovery, sarcopenia prevention

✅ Pros: Convenient, efficient way to hit protein targets; important with aging
⚠️ Cons: Varies in quality; may replace food if overused
🧬 Best for: Aging adults, athletes, low appetite individuals
🚫 Worst for: Already protein-replete individuals
♀/♂: Women often under-consume protein; more likely to benefit from protein shakes
🔬 Reference: Morton RW et al. (2018). Br J Sports Med. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2017-097608

6. Collagen Peptides
🔹 Use: Joint support, skin elasticity, connective tissue resilience

✅ Pros: Some support for aging skin and tendon integrity
⚠️ Cons: Not a complete protein; effectiveness varies by formula
🧬 Best for: Aging joints, connective tissue support
🚫 Worst for: Used as a primary protein source
♀/♂: Skin benefits often more valued and noticeable in women
🔬 Reference: Clark et al. (2008). CMRO. https://doi.org/10.1185/030079908X291967

7. Electrolyte Blends (Sodium, Potassium, Magnesium)
🔹 Use: Hydration, blood pressure, muscle cramp prevention

✅ Pros: Especially valuable for older adults or keto diets
⚠️ Cons: Can raise BP if overused
🧬 Best for: Older adults, low-carb dieters, heavy sweaters
🚫 Worst for: Hypertension or kidney disease
♀/♂: Magnesium helpful for PMS-related cramps
🔬 Wing Yin Lau, Haruyasu Kato, Kazunori Nosaka - BMJ Open Sport & Exercise Medicine 2019;5:e000478.

https://bmjopensem.bmj.com/content/5/1/e000478

8. CoQ10 (Ubiquinol)
🔹 Use: Energy production, cardiovascular health, statin fatigue mitigation

✅ Pros: Supports mitochondrial aging; fatigue reduction
⚠️ Cons: Requires bioavailable form; expensive
🧬 Best for: Statin users, chronic fatigue, aging adults
🚫 Worst for: Young, healthy individuals with high natural CoQ10
🔬 Littarru GP, Tiano L. Clinical aspects of coenzyme Q10: an update. Nutrition. 2010;26(3):250–254.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19932599/

9. Curcumin (with Piperine)
🔹 Use: Anti-inflammatory, cognitive health, joint support

✅ Pros: Natural COX-2 inhibitor; supports longevity, brain aging
⚠️ Cons: Low bioavailability unless paired with absorption enhancers
🧬 Best for: Inflammation, cognitive longevity, recovery
🚫 Worst for: Those on anticoagulants
🔬 Reference: Hewlings & Kalman (2017). Foods. https://doi.org/10.3390/foods6100092

10. Probiotics
🔹 Use: Gut health, digestion, immunity

✅ Pros: Some strains help restore gut microbiome, reduce inflammation
⚠️ Cons: Strain-specific; not universally helpful
🧬 Best for: Post-antibiotic use, GI issues
🚫 Worst for: Immune-compromised individuals or those with healthy guts
🔬 Reference: NIH Fact Sheet for Consumers - Probiotics  https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/Probiotics-Consumer/

11. Iron (if deficient)
🔹 Use: Energy, cognitive function, oxygen transport

✅ Pros: Treats anemia, boosts performance if deficient
⚠️ Cons: Toxic if overused; causes constipation
🧬 Best for: Menstruating women, vegans, endurance athletes
🚫 Worst for: Men or post-menopausal women without deficiency
♀/♂: Women are significantly more likely to benefit
🔬 Reference: Haas & Brownlie (2001). Nutr Rev. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11160598/

12. Melatonin
🔹 Use: Sleep onset, circadian alignment

✅ Pros: Effective for circadian disruption, travel, or shift work
⚠️ Cons: Not a sedative; excessive use disrupts sleep architecture
🧬 Best for: Older adults, jet-lagged or shift workers
🚫 Worst for: People with depressive tendencies or on SSRIs
♀/♂: Women may metabolize melatonin slower
🔬 Reference: Zisapel, N. (2018). British Journal of Pharmacology

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6057895/

13. Zinc
🔹 Use: Immune and hormone support

✅ Pros: Supports testosterone, immune resilience, antioxidant status
⚠️ Cons: Can deplete copper; avoid long-term high doses
🧬 Best for: Immunocompromised, older men with low testosterone
🚫 Worst for: People already taking zinc-rich multis or diets high in red meat
♀/♂: Men benefit hormonally; women require less
🔬 Reference: Haase, H., & Rink, L. (2014). Zinc signals and immune function. BioFactors, 40(1), 27–40.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23804522/

14. N-Acetyl Cysteine (NAC)
🔹 Use: Liver support, respiratory and antioxidant function

✅ Pros: Precursor to glutathione; helps detox, protects lungs
⚠️ Cons: Can interact with meds; sulfur taste/smell
🧬 Best for: Smokers, polluted areas, high oxidative stress
🚫 Worst for: Pregnant or medicated individuals without guidance
🔬 Reference: Mokhtari V, Afsharian P, Shahhoseini M, Kalantar SM, Moini A.  https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5241507/

15. Berberine
🔹 Use: Glucose regulation, insulin sensitivity

✅ Pros: Comparable to metformin in effect; supports metabolic health
⚠️ Cons: GI side effects; drug interactions
🧬 Best for: Pre-diabetic, PCOS, high triglycerides
🚫 Worst for: People on multiple prescriptions
🔬 Reference: Yin et al. (2008). Metabolism.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18442638/

16. Adaptogenic Mushrooms (Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Cordyceps)
🔹 Use: Cognitive resilience, immune modulation

✅ Pros: Emerging evidence for neuroprotection, fatigue reduction
⚠️ Cons: Sparse high-quality human studies; effects strain-dependent
🧬 Best for: Stress recovery, brain fog, immune function
🚫 Worst for: Expecting drug-level efficacy or taking immunosuppressants
🔬 Reference: Mori, K., Inatomi, S., Ouchi, K., Azumi, Y., & Tuchida, T. (2009). https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ptr.2634

17. Caffeine
🔹 Use: Energy, alertness, performance boost

✅ Pros: Enhances exercise output, mood, and focus
⚠️ Cons: Tolerance, dependence, disrupts sleep and recovery
🧬 Best for: Morning exercisers, endurance athletes
🚫 Worst for: Insomniacs, high-stress individuals
♀/♂: Women clear caffeine more slowly, especially on oral contraceptives
🔬 Reference: Cappelletti S, Piacentino D, Sani G, Aromatario M. Curr Neuropharmacol. 2015 https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4462044/

18. Fiber + Protein Blends (e.g., psyllium + pea protein)
🔹 Use: Gut health, cholesterol, satiety, glucose control

✅ Pros: Supports gut microbiome, blood sugar, and fullness
⚠️ Cons: Bloating if introduced too quickly
🧬 Best for: Aging adults with poor digestion and low protein intake
🚫 Worst for: IBS-D, low-fluid consumers
🔬 Reference: Anderson et al. (2009). Nutr Rev. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1753-4887.2009.00189.x

19. Ashwagandha (Withania somnifera)
🔹 Use: Stress adaptation, cortisol regulation

✅ Pros: Improves HRV, sleep, strength recovery
⚠️ Cons: Can interfere with thyroid meds or autoimmune issues
🧬 Best for: Overworked, anxious, under-recovered individuals
🚫 Worst for: Thyroid or autoimmune conditions without supervision
🔬 Reference: Wankhede et al. (2015). JISSN. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12970-015-0104-9

20. Multivitamins (High-Quality, Targeted)
🔹 Use: Nutrient insurance policy

✅ Pros: May cover minor gaps in micronutrient intake
⚠️ Cons: Often underdosed, low quality, not individualized
🧬 Best for: Restricted diets, older adults with low food variety
🚫 Worst for: Over-reliance without dietary changes
♀/♂: Choose gender/age-specific formulas (iron for women, etc.)
🔬 Reference: Ames BN (2006). PNAS. https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.0608757103


🚫 Not Worth It: Overrated Supplements

These commonly marketed supplements either lack strong evidence of benefit, are redundant, or may even pose risks. They don’t make the top 20 and generally aren’t worth your money—or your hope.



1. Glucosamine + Chondroitin
🧩
Claim: Joint repair and cartilage protection
Verdict: Multiple large studies show minimal to no benefit beyond placebo. Any mild effect is likely anecdotal or driven by industry bias.
🔬
Reference: Clegg et al. (2006). NEJM. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa052771

2. Branched Chain Amino Acids (BCAAs)
🧩
Claim: Boosts recovery and muscle growth
Verdict: If you consume adequate total protein, BCAAs offer no additional benefit and are a waste of money.
🔬
Reference: Wolfe RR (2017). JISSN. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12970-017-0184-9

3. Testosterone Boosters (Tribulus, Fenugreek, etc.)
🧩 Claim: Raise testosterone naturally and build muscle
❌ Verdict: Strong placebo effect but little measurable improvement in T levels or performance in healthy men.
🔬 Reference: Clemesha CG, Thaker H, Samplaski MK. World J Mens Health. 2020
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6920068/

4. Fat Burners / Thermogenics
🧩 Claim: Accelerate fat loss and metabolism

❌ Verdict: At best, slightly raise energy expenditure; at worst, are stimulant-loaded and potentially dangerous.
🔬 Reference: Clark JE, Welch S. Nutr Health. 2021  https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9987759/


Final Thoughts: Personalization Is the Key


The best supplement plan isn’t the one with the most bottles—it’s the one that matches your physiology, lifestyle, and goals. Testing (like blood panels for vitamin D, ferritin, CRP, lipids, etc.) can reveal where your body actually needs support.


And with your test results in hand, the most likely best course of action is to reevaluate your nutrition, your sleep, your exercise, your stress management, and your relationships. And then decide if you need a supplement to fill any gaps.


Partnering with a health professional can help you:

  • Interpret your labs
  • Avoid unnecessary, unsafe, or redundant supplements
  • Match your plan to your age, activity, goals, stress, and diet.

Suggested Labs


Labs to Consider for Supplement Personalization
  • Vitamin D — Check for deficiency or excess
  • Ferritin — Iron storage (especially important for women and vegans)
  • Lipid Panel — Cardiovascular health, Omega-3
  • CRP - C-Reactive Protein — Chronic inflammation marker
  • Testosterone / Estrogen / DHEA — Hormone balance
  • Magnesium RBC — Better than serum for chronic deficiency
  • Homocysteine & B12 — Methylation and cognitive aging support


I encourage you to learn more and be curious about topics like these. It's easy to get misled by what "experts" have to say and take it as fact. But with very few exceptions, scientists with the actual credentials and research are rarely on Instagram, YouTube, or TV. Sure, there are people like me who are the messengers and evangelists of this sort of information. However, my filter may come with biases, agendas, inaccuracies, or ignorance. As Timothy Leary, Ben Franklin, and Socrates used to say, Question Authority.


The sources used to support these rankings are easy to find. A Google search that begins with "NIH" (National Institute of Health) followed by whatever you're curious to learn about often leads you to a list of articles addressing your questions. ChatGPT can answer your questions and curiosities in more of a conversational manner but it's wise to ask it for its sources and fact check it. It's usually right but sometimes it's wrong.


Good luck! And I hope you found this interesting and made you more curious.

You might also enjoy these posts . . .

By Tom Wigginton April 4, 2025
Why Busy Families Might Consider Using ChatGPT for Meal Planning
Japanese Interval Walking at Vitruvian Fitness
By Tom Wigginton March 28, 2025
Until I read this study, I was firmly in the “walking is activity, not exercise” camp. Before you run me out of town, let me explain and then I’ll eat my hat. The human body is designed to seek efficiency when it comes to living, moving, and grooving. Let’s look at a slightly extreme example. Runners (in grossly simple terms) get faster and go farther because the musculoskeletal system becomes more efficient at moving the legs. The cardiovascular system becomes better at supplying oxygen to the muscles. And the cellular energy systems (remember mitochondria - the powerhouse of the cell?) improve how they produce energy and clear energy byproducts. Cyclists are the same. What may have been hard at the beginning of a training phase becomes easier with focused training. That’s efficiency.
What Are “Non-Scale Victories” and Why Do They Matter?
By Tom Wigginton March 14, 2025
Fitness, health, and wellness are too often confused with weight, but this belief is both troublesome and without merit. The number you see on the scale is just that: a number, without any insight into anything else. Not your happiness, not your health, not your speed, power, or flexibility—you get where we’re going with [...] The post What Are “Non-Scale Victories” and Why Do They Matter? appeared first on Vitruvian Fitness.
By Tom Wigginton March 9, 2025
Why Do We Foam Roll? Foam Rolling is good for you! It's like eating your broccoli for your muscles, connective tissues, and nervous system. It helps you move better and feel better. And when you move and feel better, the hard work of working out yields greater results. And when you get past the initial discomfort and difficulty of rolling various body parts (like IT Bands!), it really does feel good. What follows next are many of the very cool and somewhat nerdy things going on when you foam roll mindfully, thoroughly, with intention, and curiosity. Improving Flexibility and Movement Quality Foam rolling, a widely used form of self-myofascial release (SMR), helps improve mobility by reducing excessive muscle tension and promoting better movement patterns. By applying pressure to the muscles and surrounding connective tissue, foam rolling enhances flexibility and range of motion, making it a valuable tool for both performance and recovery. Foam rolling primarily addresses two common soft tissue restrictions: Adhesions – Areas where muscle and connective tissue become less mobile due to poor hydration, overuse, or microtrauma. Rolling encourages better fluid movement and tissue elasticity. Trigger Points – Small, hyperactive muscle knots where fibers stay contracted, limiting function. Rolling doesn’t physically break up these knots but instead signals the nervous system to relax the area. By improving these tissue qualities, foam rolling enhances movement efficiency and joint function, reducing compensatory patterns that may lead to injury. Enhancing Circulation and Recovery Foam rolling promotes increased blood flow, aiding in oxygen delivery, nutrient transport, and the removal of metabolic waste products from muscle tissue. This effect can support faster recovery, reduce soreness, and maintain tissue health over time. Improving Neuromuscular Activation By stimulating sensory receptors in the muscles and fascia, foam rolling enhances neuromuscular control. This can improve muscle activation and coordination, leading to better performance and more efficient movement patterns. Proprioception and Body Awareness Foam rolling provides sensory feedback that enhances proprioception—the body's ability to sense its position and movement in space. Improved proprioception leads to better balance, stability, and movement accuracy, which are critical for both athletic performance and injury prevention. Foam Rolling as a Warm-Up Tool While foam rolling is often associated with recovery, it also plays a key role in pre-exercise preparation. By improving tissue elasticity, modulating neural tone, and increasing blood flow, foam rolling can help prime muscles for activity. This makes it a valuable addition to dynamic warm-up routines, reducing stiffness and enhancing readiness for training. Preventing Injuries Through Regular Use Using foam rolling regularly allows individuals to identify tight or overactive areas before they develop into movement dysfunctions or injuries. Sensitivity in a specific area often indicates excessive muscle tension or imbalance. Addressing these issues early can prevent them from escalating into chronic problems. Optimizing Strength and Performance By reducing unnecessary tension and improving force transmission efficiency, foam rolling contributes to better movement mechanics and overall performance. When muscles function optimally, athletes can generate more power with less fatigue, improving training quality and long-term results. Supporting Posture and Musculoskeletal Health Many people develop muscle imbalances due to prolonged sitting or repetitive movements. Foam rolling can help alleviate excess tightness in overworked areas, promoting better posture and reducing stress on the joints. This is particularly important for individuals who experience discomfort from prolonged sedentary behavior. The Psychological and Sensory Benefits Beyond the physical benefits, foam rolling can have a relaxing effect by stimulating the parasympathetic nervous system. As muscles release tension, many individuals experience a sense of relief and improved well-being. The combination of proprioceptive input, deep breathing, and movement awareness can make foam rolling a valuable recovery and stress-management tool. Does Foam Rolling Change Tissue Structure? One arguable aspect of foam rolling is that it "breaks up" adhesions in muscle tissue. Some people says it does indeed. Others say that while it does improve tissue mobility, the main effect is neurological rather than structural. Foam rolling influences the nervous system to decrease muscle tension and enhance circulation, creating an environment where connective tissue can gradually adapt and remodel over time. Some also argue that because you're not stretching or lengthening your connective tissues, you shouldn't bother. But stretching isn't the point and we never said that's what we were trying to accomplish. How to Maximize the Benefits of Foam Rolling To get the most out of foam rolling, consider these evidence-based strategies: Move Slowly – Spend at least 30-60 seconds on each muscle group, applying steady pressure. Breathe Deeply – Deep breathing promotes relaxation and allows muscles to release tension more effectively. Pause on Tight Spots – If you find a tender area, hold pressure there for a few seconds until discomfort diminishes. Use Different Angles – Slightly shifting positions can target different layers of tissue and enhance the effect. Integrate Thoughtfully – Foam rolling should be part of a structured training plan, used before workouts for activation and after workouts for recovery. Choosing the Right Foam Rolling Tools A basic foam roller is often sufficient, but more specialized tools—such as massage balls, percussion devices, or resistance bands—can provide targeted relief based on individual needs. The right tool depends on factors like muscle density, sensitivity, and training goals. Conclusion: A Smart Approach to Tissue Care Strength training and athletic performance aren’t just about lifting heavier or moving faster—they’re also about preparing the body for optimal function. Foam rolling is a simple yet effective method to improve mobility, enhance muscle readiness, and promote long-term resilience.  Many individuals report immediate improvements in movement quality and reduced discomfort when foam rolling is used correctly. However, persistent pain despite proper soft tissue work may indicate a more serious underlying issue that requires assessment by a physical therapist or healthcare professional. Key Takeaways Monitor movement quality and address restrictions early. Apply slow, intentional pressure while maintaining controlled breathing. Use foam rolling strategically as part of a comprehensive training program. Combine foam rolling with strength and mobility work for best results. Train smart, recover well, and maximize your potential.
By Tom Wigginton February 28, 2025
For decades, the standard advice for managing sprains, strains, and soft tissue injuries has been the well-known RICE method — Re st, Ice, Compression, and Elev ation . This simple and memorabl e acronym has been widely accepted by athletes, medical professionals, and everyday individuals as the go-to strategy for reducing swelling and pain after an injury. However, recent research suggests that while some components of RICE remain valuable, the emphasis on rest and ice may actually hinder the body’s natural healing process rather than support it. Unless you spend countless hours reading about exercise, rehab, and performance, it might be natural to think that resting an injured body part and applying ice is a great way to recover. After all, conventional wisdom tells us that inflammation is bad, swelling is something to be avoided, and pain relief should come first. But what if we told you that your body’s natural response to injury—mild inflammation—isn’t the enemy, and that immobilization might actually do more harm than good?
By Tom Wigginton February 20, 2025
What having a bunch of friends helping you move has in common with functional training.
Show More
Share by: